Advertise Here
Deliver your message to thousands of readers every day.
Our readers are influential opinion makers - politicians, journalists and activists.
Our latest headlines
- Weekly Radio Address: Assembly Lead Water Negotiators Huffman, Caballero Discuss this Week’s Historic Agreement to Solve California’s Water Crisis
- Feinstein Once Again Flirts With Entering the Governor’s Race
- A Good Health Care Bill Emerging from the House
- Schwarzenegger Applauds Passage of Peripheral Canal/Dams Water Package
- "Historic" Water Deal Draws Both Praise and Criticism
- Republican State Senators Vote for Administrative Chaos, Backdoor Cuts in IHSS
- Assembly Budget Committee Follow-up Informational Hearing on Implementation on IHSS Program Changes
About Us
David Greenwald, Editor. (Contact David.)
CFC Education Foundation, Publisher. (Contact us.)
Got a news tip? Want to write a guest column?
Contact David here.
About California Progress Report.
Founded by Frank D. Russo (Publisher and Editor, 2006-08).
Sponsors
Books
California Already Spends More Than 4 Times More Per Prisoner Than Per Public School Student—Prop 9 Would Make That Worse
By Marty Hittelman
President
California Federation of Teachers
The November 4th general election is an important election for public education, even though none of the Propositions directly address schools. That’s because many of the propositions would have an impact on the conditions under which education takes place, and would have a deep impact on our students and their families.
Prop. 9, for example, could siphon hundreds of millions of dollars from public education. It takes money away from schools, children’s healthcare and other programs to incarcerate future criminals. Prop. 9 requires increased spending on corrections, but doesn’t provide one additional dollar. Thus, its passage means money would be taken from education and other programs to fund Prop. 9. That’s just what we don’t need.
California already has a 15 billion dollar budget deficit. California cannot afford to SPEND ANY LESS ON schools while spending even more on a prisons plan that does not address the real needs of victims.
Prop. 9 is a misleading proposition that exploits Californians’ concern for crime victims. It preys on our emotions in order to rewrite the State Constitution, and change the way California manages its prisons and jails, threatening to worsen our overcrowding crises, at both the state and local levels. Prop. 9 is a costly, unnecessary initiative. It does little to extend the current Victims’ Bill of Rights.
In addition, Prop. 9’s tremendously costly changes to existing parole policy are unjustified on either a cost or a value basis.
Prop. 9 would deepen California’s deficit, and would require the state to build more prisons throughout California. According to the independent Legislative Analyst's Office, this would "amount to hundreds of millions of dollars annually”. This is an unnecessary burden on California taxpayers.
California is dealing with the worst budget crisis in its history, facing a record deficit. This is not the time for the passage of an unnecessary ballot measure that burdens taxpayers by pouring millions into a measure that does not adequately address the problems facing victims.
All Californians are understandably concerned about safety and are sympathetic to crime victims. However, while we share these concerns and have the utmost sympathy for crime victims and their families, Proposition 9 (Marsy’s Law) is not the answer.
The propositions are not the only items on the ballot that will impact public education. Those legislators make the decisions on state education funding. Electing legislators sympathetic to public education is also vital, especially in light of the just concluded budget battle. We need to elect people willing to establish a bottom line for state revenues so that we can deliver the quality public education and social services we need and deserve.
Marty Hittelman, a community college math professor from Los Angeles, is the President of the California Federation of Teachers (CFT) which is a member of the American Federation of Teachers (AFT). The CFT represents faculty and other school employees in public and private schools and colleges, from early childhood through higher education in California.
Comments
Children are the most important aspect to our society. Education is crucial to our existence in the world economy! Our crimminals enjoy a lifestyle to be admired by most, other then freedom to move at will, all benefits are provided that on the outside one cannot afford. Perhaps if prison was truly an undesirable place to be we might have less crime!!!
Posted by: Pam at September 24, 2008 01:15 PM
Maybe if the Teachers Unions would withhold contributions to legislators that support giving the Prison Guards outrageous raises and benefits the cost of housing prisoners would come down. Furthermore a quality education is not dependent on spending more money on public schools, the vast majority of kids who are pulled out of the public schools and are home schooled are exceptionally well prepared for college. Parental involvement trumps public spending every time and lack of parental involvement will result in failure regardless of how much money is spent.
Posted by: sean at September 24, 2008 02:01 PM
Pam & Sean is RIGHT ON with their comments.
Further, I see convicts living in tents with no TV nor work out facilities, etc., working off their sentence besides roadsides and picking crops and the like as another way to reduce the cost of their incarceration/penance to society.
And all the money "saved" by this lessoning cost of incarceration will go to education.
Who amongst the left will join in this endeavor?
Posted by: Jay Gould at September 24, 2008 09:08 PM
I am so thrilled to see that the teacher's unions are finally connecting the dots. Educators have an immediate stake in the obsese prison budget because it starves other government programs. Every extra dollar we spend on prisons will be a dollar we take away from somewhere else.
I hope CTA will have the courage and foresight to join CFT in this dire struggle.
Posted by: Bearerfriend at September 25, 2008 12:59 AM
Mr. Hittleman makes an argument that giving victims of violent crime a standing and constitutional rights in the criminal justice system somehow takes money away from education. I strongly disagree and will send Mr. Hittleman a point by point answer; I believe he is a fair man and will give it serious consideration. Victims believe the same as society, many of us are union members; we want education excellence, we support teachers and their unions. We are shocked that our desires for victim’s equity and justice are attacked, and that we are characterized as simplistic boobs who want a "feel good" law at the expense of education. That is not true: victims want children in safe class rooms, and, we want violent criminals - murderers, rapists, violent thugs and molesters - in jail and prison!
Victims are in earnest that the criminal justice system be balanced and that we have standing and a voice in the crimes that affect, or ruin, our lives. Most opposition spokespersons have not talked to victims or tried to understand our need and the intensity we have. When you hear our stories, Prop 9 will be put in context; you will understand why we want change.
I have a niece who is a wonderful teacher in California; she is an avid union member and negotiator. Our daughter, her cousin, was brutally murdered, stabbed over 40 times, on a dark campus parking lot. My niece has seen how the justice system has jerked our family around, has excluded our family and Robbin's friends from having any voice. I think many teachers have suffered crime, been a victim themselves, or experienced it through family and friends. Is their union telling them to vote against Prop 9, vote against victim justice, vote against what their head and heart know is right, in order to be a good member? I hope not.
Let the victims educate you on why Prop 9 is a fight worth winning for all union members. If the population of teachers resembles society at large, then a large portion have been affected by crime and they understand the need for Prop 9.
Victims are good citizens, not dupes or emotional fools trying to raid the treasury to build more jails. We do want to keep murders, violent thugs, rapists and molesters in prison, not in your neighborhoods, not near your schools.
Thank you for reading this. I appreciate your comments on the Friends of Marsy's Law - Vote YES on Prop 9 blog at www.friendsofmarsyslaw.org
Victims are not your enemies.
Note: the National Tax Limitation Committee recommends a YES vote on Prop 9. Their comments are: "California's constitution guarantees rights for murderers, child molesters and dangerous criminals. Prop 9 levels the playing field, guaranteeing crime victims the right to justice and due process ending further victimization of innocent people by a system that frequently neglects, ignores and forever punishes them."
Amen!!
Posted by: Jack Reilley at September 28, 2008 12:56 PM
Sorry, comments are temporarily disabled. We're doing a bit of server maintenance on the commenting area. We'll be back up and running shortly. Thank you for your patience.
Get Email Updates
Want the California Progress Report by email? Once a week, we'll send you the latest and greatest headlines.
© 2008 California Progress Report Our copyright and fair use policy.
Powered by Mandate Media. Logo design by Jane Norling.
RSS 