Advertise Here
Deliver your message to thousands of readers every day.
Our readers are influential opinion makers - politicians, journalists and activists.
Our latest headlines
- Weekly Radio Address: Assembly Lead Water Negotiators Huffman, Caballero Discuss this Week’s Historic Agreement to Solve California’s Water Crisis
- Feinstein Once Again Flirts With Entering the Governor’s Race
- A Good Health Care Bill Emerging from the House
- Schwarzenegger Applauds Passage of Peripheral Canal/Dams Water Package
- "Historic" Water Deal Draws Both Praise and Criticism
- Republican State Senators Vote for Administrative Chaos, Backdoor Cuts in IHSS
- Assembly Budget Committee Follow-up Informational Hearing on Implementation on IHSS Program Changes
About Us
David Greenwald, Editor. (Contact David.)
CFC Education Foundation, Publisher. (Contact us.)
Got a news tip? Want to write a guest column?
Contact David here.
About California Progress Report.
Founded by Frank D. Russo (Publisher and Editor, 2006-08).
Sponsors
Books
Where's the California Budget? Who Is Obstructing?
By Dave Johnson
Speak Out California
One more attempt to get a state budget in place collapsed -- blocked by the Republicans because it included tax increases. Republicans insist that the budget be balanced with billions and billions of dollars in cuts in our schools and fire protection and the other things most of us want our state to do.
I would bet that most of California's public doesn't know what is going on with our budget. They only know that there isn't one, and that this is causing problems. It makes people angry, and causes them to lose faith in government.
People know that government employees are being forced to take pay cuts, and many are being laid off. But they really do not know why.
Yesterday's budget vote was 45-30. The public doesn't understand that this means that there were forty-five votes FOR the budget and only thirty votes against, and this is why it failed. They don't understand that because it does not make sense. But because of a trick that the Republicans were able to play on the public the rules are that it takes a two-thirds vote to pass a budget. So an overwhelming vote of 45-30 FOR the budget means that the budget does NOT pass!
Every Republican in the state has taken a vow not to raise taxes on wealthy corporations or massively wealthy individuals. They won't vote to require people who buy yachts or private jets to pay the same sales taxes that the rest of us pay when we buy cars. They refuse to ask oil companies to pay fees when they take our oil out of the ground and sell it to us. (Maybe they understand that such a vote will dry up their campaign funding...)
News stories about the latest budget collapse:
Although the $105.2 billion budget blueprint garnered a majority vote, 45-30, it fell short of the two-thirds supermajority that California's constitution requires to pass a budget.
. . . The vote "shows clearly that we're not going to vote for taxes," said Assembly Republican leader Mike Villines, R-Fresno.
"We're fundamentally saying 'no tax increases,'" said Mike Villines, the Assembly Republican leader.
They will require workers to take pay cuts and layoffs. They will cut our school budgets. They will cut transportation, the DMV, road repair, law enforcement, prisons, fire protection. But they will not ask wealthy corporations or extremely wealthy individuals to pitch in.
And here is why: by and large California's public doesn't know this. They are not being informed that this is entirely because a small minority of Republicans refuse to represent the public's interests, choosing to represent the wealthy corporations and wealthiest few people.
In fact, the public likely believes that it is the Democrats who are keeping the budget from being passed. If you Google the word Democrat with the word obstruction and you get about 600,000 results.
This is a national result, but it reflects the same strategy in use in California. Republicans spent years accusing Democrats of being "obstructionist" when they were not, as a strategy to pressure them to pass Republican-/corporate-oriented bills. Now, after blocking almost everything that the nation's Congress is doing, the Republicans are campaigning saying that the Democrats in Congress aren't passing anything! Meanwhile a new Drum Major Institute polls shows that 72% of middle-class Americans can't name a single bill passed by Congress in the last two years that benefited them or their families! (Minimum wage increase, stimulus package, college more affordable, SCHIP...)
Less than two in five (38%) middle-class respondents to the Drum Major Institute's new poll say they live comfortably. One-third (34%) say they meet their basic expenses each month with just a little left over for extras, while one-quarter (26%) of middle-class adults would say they just meet their basic expenses (17%) or have trouble meeting their basic expenses each month (9%). And, economy and jobs tops their concerns. They are pessimistic about the direction of the economy. They think it's more likely that Brangelina will celebrate their 25th anniversary than gas prices returning to $3 a gallon.
But they do not understand WHY. They don't make the connection between the corporate-controlled Republican party and what is happening to the country.
How do Republicans get away with this? How are they able to get the public to think so many things that are not true? The Republicans have a vast "noise machine" that tells the public things that are not true. (Remember how they were able to convince so many people that Iraq had attacked us on 9/11?) It costs a lot of money to have a noise machine like this, but they get the money from the very corporations and wealthy individuals whose interests they are representing. So it works for them.
Plain and simple, they are bale to reach the public and tell them stuff, and get the public to believe it. The use of overwhelming repetition is the tactic. I use the word "stuff" here with meaning: it's just stuff they want the public to believe, with no grounding in reality. They do it, and here we are. Nationally the debt is approaching TEN TRILLION DOLLARS and they are still able to get the public to think taxes are bad. In California they are able to force layoffs and school cuts while refusing to make the ultra-rich pay even the same taxes the rest of us pay.
Please leave comments with suggestions on how to fight this.
Dave Johnson is the founder and principal author at Seeing the Forest, a web magazine investigating how the right is beating the Democrats. He is a fellow at the Commonweal Institute, a Board of Directors member of Media Transparency, an advisor to The Philanthropy Network, and a member of the Netroots Advisory Council of the Drum Major Institute. This article originally appeared on the website of Speak Out California Speak Out California and is republished with permission.
Comments
Dave,
In your "Who is obstructing the California Budget" segment, you predictably hang it on the Republicans...
But your intellectual honesty and/or attention to critical details are "missing" as you did not point out how Democrat Assemblymember Nicole Parra didn't vote for the budget discussed here either.
Why didn't you mention this detail in your "analysis" here?
Or is it just better propaganda to only "bash" Republicans?
By the way, if Republicans are so "corporate controlled", then why do SO MANY corporations AND UNIONS contribute campaign cash to Democratic candidates? Wouldn't those entities control Democrats with their money using your same yardstick you applied to Republicans?
Heck, even Obama has at last look accepted $1.5 million in donations from oil entities. Use your search engine with "Obama Oil Company Contributions" and see for yourself what NPR, the LA Times and others say on this.
Is there a "Democratic Noise Machine" too? I mean, if Republicans "talked us" into the Iraq War via 9-11, why do so many Democrats in Congress KEEP FUNDING THE WAR? Their Congressional majority in 2006 was established to END THE WAR, yet they continue to FUND IT. (Couldn't that money reduce the national debt you mention?)
Obama has shifted from "ending the war" to lets stay for 16 MORE MONTHS. How many more American's will needlessly be killed in those 16 months?
Posted by: Jay Gould at August 20, 2008 10:33 AM
Dave,
In your article, you cited that "Less than two in five (38%) middle-class respondents to the Drum Major Institute's new poll say they live comfortably." So more money should be taken away from them in a very tough economy? The median income in California is about 47K per year. The highest CA state income tax kicks in at 45K per year - 9%! It's not just the rich and corporations that pay taxes, although the do pay the vast majority.
Even Obama has recognized that higher taxes in a bad economy is a horrendous idea. CA unemployment is nearing ten percent. This is the time to put more money in the hands of a Californian not take it away. Californians are over taxed, not under taxed.
Posted by: Ron at January 24, 2009 12:35 PM
This budget "blurb" is definitely the work of a Democrat!
I changed my political party from Demo. to Rep. exactly for this reason (along with exaggerated smut slinging).
Our budget was not ruined by Bush policy. It was ruined by the policy that needed to be instituted by what occurred at 911 and bad intelligence from our sources (undoubtedly Democrats)! Would the Bush administration have profited or gained approval if they had done nothing?
Posted by: Walter Arnold at February 19, 2009 12:08 PM
Sorry, comments are temporarily disabled. We're doing a bit of server maintenance on the commenting area. We'll be back up and running shortly. Thank you for your patience.
Get Email Updates
Want the California Progress Report by email? Once a week, we'll send you the latest and greatest headlines.
© 2008 California Progress Report Our copyright and fair use policy.
Powered by Mandate Media. Logo design by Jane Norling.
RSS 