Advertise Here
Deliver your message to thousands of readers every day.
Our readers are influential opinion makers - politicians, journalists and activists.
Our latest headlines
- Tonight We Celebrate the California Supreme Court Decision for Marriage Equality--Tomorrow We Fight
- California Declares Marriage Equality for All-- A Watershed for Basic Fairness and Human Dignity
- Governor Schwarzenegger Opposes Any Move to Overturn California Supreme Court Decision on Sam Sex Marriage—Ruling Celebrated by Many
- Historic California Supreme Court Ruling Upholds Constitutional Right to Gay Marriage and Strikes Down Statutes and Initiative
- Governor's California May Budget Revision Makes Deeper Health Cuts
- Latest Schwarzenegger Budget Plan Slashes In-Home Supportive Services Which Helps 408,000 Elderly, Blind or Disabled Californians Live Safely At Home
- Schwarzenegger Again Proposes Taking from California Public Transportation—Only This Time Gas is at $4 a Gallon
About Us
The California Progress Report is published by Frank D. Russo, a longtime observer of and participant in California politics.
About Frank Russo.
About California Progress Report.
Got a news tip? Want to write a guest column? Contact Frank here.
Sponsors
Delta Flows: Schwarzenegger Pushes Dangerous Amendments to Perata's Water Bond Proposal
By Barbara Barrigan-Parrilla
Campaign Director
Restore the Delta
Restore the Delta staff has been monitoring how the two special session water bonds SB2xx (Perata) and SB3xx (Cogdill), which were both defeated in the State Senate last week, will be repackaged and offered up to voters as initiatives in the months to come.
To date, we have heard mostly through the media that Senate President pro Tem, Don Perata, has suggested that specific surface water storage projects could be named and incorporated into his bond proposal. To date, this specific change seems to be all the Senate President pro Tem is willing to alter within his bond proposal.
However, new language, being pushed by Governor Schwarzenegger’s office as amendments to Senator Perata’s bond proposal, echoes what we found to be disturbing in Senator Cogdill’s SB 3xx. (Delta Flows readers will remember that Restore the Delta opposed Senator Cogdill’s bond proposal as it contained language giving authorization for funding the construction of an alternative conveyance system to divert fresh water away from entering the Delta.)
Restore the Delta Board Member, and Planning and Conservation League Water Expert, Mindy McIntyre, recently shared the following information regarding the Governor’s proposed amendments with Restore the Delta staff. (Comments in brackets and italics are information and commentary additions from Restore the Delta.)
• The area of origin language explicitly excludes the Delta. (Laws pertaining to area of origin protect water user rights within California.) You can guess why the Governor would want to strip the Delta of Area of Origin. In addition, the language states that the area of origin as established in the bill (excluding the Delta) would have to have a two-thirds vote of the legislature to change or repeal. That would be nearly impossible. (In other words, if this language were to slide by voters in a bond initiative it would be nearly impossible to change or alter this language to protect local Delta water users through the legislative process.)
• --The proposed language from the Governor’s office states that the Department Water Resources (DWR) has the existing authority to “implement” a conveyance and sustainability solution. Such language would become law and actually give DWR the authority to build the peripheral canal or pipe without legislative oversight. (Again, the Governor is seeking to work around rather than with the Delta Vision Process which he mandated.)
• --The Governor strikes out important language in the Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) section. Essentially, the Governor’s amendments would eliminate the need for the BDCP to comply with California Endangered Species Act. This is important because it implies that BDCP will just be used like the Environmental Water Account and other “restoration” programs. Essentially these programs, rather than restoring the Delta, are used to set a (minimum) baseline level of (water) resources, and if the Delta, (a flexible ecosystem) needs more fresh water, then too bad. (Delta fresh water allocations would be set as static, when current science and water export records indicate that a good part of the Delta’s ecosystem problems have resulted from too much water being pumped out of the Delta in dry years. In addition, we once again see the Governor seeking to bypass working collaboratively with Delta stakeholders and environmental groups.)
Ms. McIntyre added, “The people in the Delta should know that this is what the Governor is pushing. Everyone else is focused on the dams, but this language would setup the final collapse of the Delta.”
Fortunately, Local Government Entities Are Stepping Up To Advocate For the Delta
At last week’s Natural Resources & Water Committee Hearing on the proposed water bonds by Senator Perata (SB2x) and Senator Cogdill (SB3x), San Joaquin County Supervisor Ken Vogel testified to the committee on the Board’s opposition to a peripheral canal or conveyance system, and the harm that it would bring to the Delta and San Joaquin County.
In fact, the San Joaquin County Board of Supervisors is one of the first local government entities within the Delta to recognize the threat that is being made to our community and to make such a formal statement in opposition to the peripheral canal. Moreover, the Board of Supervisors proclaimed their support for Tom Zuckerman’s plan for Regional Water Self-Sufficiency – one of the alternative visions for the Delta offered to the Blue Ribbon Task Force heading up the Delta Vision Process – a plan that Restore the Delta agrees would help to lessen water dependency on the Delta by other regions throughout the state.
Restore the Delta applauds the San Joaquin County Board of Supervisors for making their position on this critical Delta issue known, and encourages other local government entities throughout the Delta to make similar statements and proclamations regarding their opposition to the peripheral canal/pipe public. We are also encouraging local Delta stakeholders to begin working with local government entities to help bring about the creation of such public statements.
And While We All Talk, The Fish Keep Dying…
While the Restore the Delta campaign advocates primarily to restore and protect fresh water levels passing through the Delta, and maintains that adequate fresh water will do a great deal to help restore the Delta’ ecosystem, we are also concerned about pollutants that also degrade water quality. Restore the Delta affirms that not one industry or group is responsible for the degradation of Delta water quality. But rather, it is a collective problem that we need to solve together through cooperation, dialogue, and positive action with a sense of urgency.
With that said, our friend and supporter, Bill Maxwell, who lives on Smith Canal sent us a disturbing series of pictures last week. After the first rain each autumn, the fish in their part of the Delta die. We have no commentary to add, as these pictures speak to us directly as to what is wrong with the Delta. But, as one child of Restore the
Delta staff asked, “Will there by any fish left?”
Restore the Delta is a grassroots campaign of residents and organizations committed to restoring the California Delta so that its waters are fishable, swimmable, drinkable, and farmable.
Comments
Rubbish. The Delta's problem is rubbish, too much pollution. The solution is not dilution, more and more water for less and less fish. The Solution is less Pollution.
I'm convinced the cause of the Bay Area Delta's crisis is simply too many people in too small an area using too many harmful chemicals. If you really want to save the Delta, Plan A is for you to MOVE! And take your house and business with you. If you can't or won't do that, then we must go to Plan B: Use less harmful chemicals. "Who, me? I'm using harmful chemicals?" Yes, you!
Most people today just don't realize how harmful our common useful chemicals are to our native fish. Take ethylene glycol for instance, the ordinary anti-freeze you use in your car. A single drop will kill a whole aquarium of many different kinds of fish. A few grams will kill a large animal within days. Thousands of children were even killed this year in and around Panama by a stupid, greedy, Chinese businessman who replaced the expensive glycerine sweetener in children's cough syrup with the much cheaper ethylene glycol. Other stupid Chinese manufacturers were even using it to sweeten toothpaste!
My point is, 50 years ago nobody in warmer climates like California used ethylene glycol in their radiators. They just used water and were careful in very cold weather. Today everyone uses antifreeze, and we have many, many millions more cars. When you add motor oil and transmission fluid to the mix, in concentrated areas like around the Bay, it's a big problem.
But simply flushing the Bay with more and more water won't fix it. Your Bill Maxwell's observation is exactly right, "After the first rain each autumn, the fish in their part of the Delta die." The problem is that all summer long in the cities surrounding the Bay cars drop anti-freeze, motor oil, and trans fluid onto the highways. When the first rains hit, it all washes into the streams. The result: Toxic Shock.
So what's this pollution solution? The first thing I'd like to see is ethylene glycol replaced with a harmless substitute. There must be many benign substances that can be used to lower the freezing point of water in our radiators. It's time to find them and use them. Oil bath engines and transmissions will take much longer to phase out, but it will be done eventually. The ultimate automobile pollution solution may simply be all electric based cars, like the new one from Tesla Motors in South San Francisco. In the mean time, cities around the Bay should be looking at collecting and treating most of our storm drain runoff, especially in the first few hours of rainstorms.
Posted by: Z. Schubert at October 17, 2007 09:38 AM
Post a comment
Get Email Updates
Want the California Progress Report by email? Once a week, we'll send you the latest and greatest headlines.
© 2008 California Progress Report Our copyright and fair use policy.
Powered by Mandate Media. Logo design by Jane Norling.
RSS 